Unlike a criminal trial, where the government must prove guilt “beyond a reasonable doubt,” an administrative separation board uses the “Preponderance of the Evidence” standard.

  • The 51% Rule: The board only needs to believe that it is “more likely than not” that the alleged misconduct occurred to recommend your separation.
  • No Rules of Evidence: These boards are not bound by the strict rules of evidence found in courts-martial, meaning hearsay and uncorroborated reports are often used against you.

FAQ – Board of Inquiry

  • Is a Board of Inquiry (BOI) the same as a court-martial? No. A BOI is a formal administrative hearing, not a criminal trial. While it cannot result in jail time, it is the primary tool used to involuntarily fire an officer from the military and can result in the loss of all veteran benefits and your retirement pension.
  • What is the burden of proof at a BOI? The standard is “Preponderance of the Evidence,” which is significantly lower than the “Beyond a Reasonable Doubt” standard used in criminal courts. The government only needs to prove that it is “more likely than not” (50.1%) that the misconduct occurred.
  • Can I be forced to retire at a lower rank if I lose my board?  Yes.  For officers, Navy and Marine Corps BOIs will make a formal recommendation regarding an officer’s retirement grade if that officer is eligible for retirement.  For Army and Air Force officers, the adverse finding at a BOI can trigger a Grade Determination Review Board (GDRB), which evaluates whether you served satisfactorily in your current rank.  Finally, for enlisted servicemembers, a BOI do not make formal recommendations about reducing rank, but the findings of an enlisted BOI will, in some cases, be considered when a retirement-eligible servicemember attempts to retire in lieu of administrative separation (as per AR 635-200).
  • Do I have the right to a JAG lawyer at my elimination board? You have the right to be represented by counsel, but the military often provides only a junior JAG who may have only done a few boards before yours, if any. Because your entire career and retirement are at stake, many choose to hire independent civilian counsel with specialized experience in officer elimination defense.
  • Can the outcome of a BOI be appealed? Yes, there are a few opportunities to challenge a BOI’s findings and recommendations, but these windows are narrow and difficult to win.  First, all servicemember may submit matters to the BOI’s convening authority, raising errors and arguing for a different outcome.  Recommendations for separation are reviewed by the Service Secretary or a designated authority who makes the final decision.

We Serve Where You Serve

Joint Base Lewis-McChord | Joint Base Elmendorf-Richardson | Fort Wainwright | Naval Base Kitsap | Joint Base San-Antonio | Fairchild AFB | Mountain Home AFB | Malmstrom AFB | USCG Kodiak | Fort Huachuca | Fort Irwin | Ellsworth AFB | FE Warren AFB | Fort Leavenworth | Fort Johnson | Fort Eisenhower | Hill AFB | Beale AFB | Minot AFB | Grand Forks AFB | Fort Liberty | Fort Cavazos | Fort Riley | Fort Stewart | Fort Moore | USCG Sector Puget Sound | Fort Carson, Peterson SFB, Air Force Academy | Wright-Patterson AFB | Military District of Washington